Sorry. That's the second time I've tried going for something less than two years old. Kamisama Dolls was my favorite show in the season it aired. It was pretty underappreciated. I've already got the blu-ray set pre-ordered. As far as good shows that year went, though, Madoka, Steins;Gate, and Fate/Zero ate up all the hype (and rightfully so, since they're all incredible). Nice choice for the new one. That was another show I felt was pretty underappreciated. It took a bit to get going, so I saw a lot of people drop it.
Yeah, I loved this anime, but it had the unfortunate fate of airing at the same time as Madoka... so it was swept into the shadows XD I'm also the kind of person that doesn't drop shows, if I start something, I watch it through to the end, regardless of how slow they start. Doing so has lead me to some rather decent shows though, so I stick with it :P